hey you! sign up and become a contributing writer to this site! no blogging experience required! register here then leave a comment here!!
« Representative Thaddeus McCotter on the auto bailout
» RockYou Detroit

We need an auto industry bailout

11.21.08 | technician | In auto

Last week Representative Thaddeus McCotter of Livonia spoke passionately about the real needs for preventing the collapse of the auto industry but we still failed to pass anything to help the auto industry. Now, if you read back through this blog you’ll know that I don’t have any particular love for cars or the automotive industry. What I do care about is the economy in particular the US economy. I like when it’s stable and not in crisis mode where fear runs through the streets and business activity stops. I don’t like when every day we hear that the economy has yet again experienced something unprecedented or which last occurred during the Great Depression.

These are interesting times.

After all that’s recently happened to our economy I fear what could happen if it were to experience another devastating economic shock. That’s what the sudden collapse of the domestic auto industry would be. The Big 3 directly employ a quarter of a million people and up to 2 million indirectly. But I’ve read estimates that if only one of the Big 3 were to go into bankruptcy 2.5 million jobs would be lost next year. Our economy has already been bleeding millions of jobs causing a downward spiral effect that has not stopped.

“If GM were to discontinue operations, the cost to local, state, and federal governments could reach $156.4 billion over three years in lost taxes, and unemployment and health care assistance.”

Automakers are different from other companies that might go in to bankruptcy. If I buy a television from a company that goes bankrupt I might lose the warranty but most likely the television wasn’t going to have any problems anyways and if it did I was probably planning on replacing it soon and either way it’s not a huge amount of money. But when it comes to cars, no matter who breaks them expensive things inside them will break and a warranty is essential. Enough people would stop buying cars from that company because of warranty fears that the company would spiral down until those fears became reality. So that’s how bankruptcy, which is supposed to protect a company, would actually do the opposite in the case of car companies.

“The idea that the U.S. economy is based on unfettered free markets is, and has long been, a cruel joke.” - Eugene Robinson , The Washington Post

These are interesting times. Perhaps in another down cycle of the auto industry the rest of the economy might have been stable enough to withstand the loss of millions of auto related jobs. But what we’ve seen is a collapse of the global financial system, the free market showing that it can only exist with outside help. Free marketeers would have said that no governments anywhere in the world should have done anything after the economic destruction of October 2008 but clearly doing nothing was not a choice. It’s not clear that the things that governments did do were the right things but we saw how markets reacted when we tested the idea of doing nothing.

The main argument that people bring up for not helping the auto industry is that in a purely free market governments should not stick their fingers in any company due to the moral hazard of not allowing certain companies to be punished. The conditions we are seeing now are not normal nor is the credit freeze any fault of the automakers. It’s true that automakers have been losing money recently and part of this is due to the restructuring that they have already been undergoing new regulations that have been imposed on the industry by the government. So the failure of the credit markets came at a particularly vulnerable time for the auto industry.

The thing is whether we choose to make the “morally correct” decision to stabilize the financial system or auto industry. What’s at stake is the entire economy. There is a point at which one single thing is too big to fail because sudden failure would cause such a shock to the market that the free market would not be able to cope. It’s like catching a cold many times over versus getting hit by a car. And actually right now our economy is so weak that even colds can be dangerous. The time to punish a child and teach them a lesson is not when they are sick in bed. Right now we need to be doing everything we can to stop the bleeding, stabilize the economy, keep it from falling into a long depression, and try to return to normalcy.

I’m not surprised that most bloggers are against the auto industry. But I think they’re discounting how much of our economy depends on the auto industry as well as how difficult it is to start and run a car company. Start up a automakers like Tesla and AFS are also now begging the federal government for hundreds of millions of dollars before they’ve even produced anything.


Leave a comment

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. Subscribe to these comments.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>



« Representative Thaddeus McCotter on the auto bailout
» RockYou Detroit
mixing zoloft and aleve hydroxychloroquine doxycycline interaction imuran dog side effects isotretinoin for mild persistent acne zyban and hair loss metoprolol general anesthesia topamax blood glucose lamictal and obsessive thoughts role of clindamycin in malaria treatment asacol and chemotherapy baclofen strengths provigil what to tell doctor topamax fibromyalgia pain what would happen if you took provera while pregnant can you get high off of meclizine hydrochloride do provigil side effects go away what classification is lamictal does neurontin contain aspirin what is better propecia or rogaine tegretol and dilantin interaction tums and zantac together urologist finasteride can you take ativan and metoprolol triamcinolone cream for bug bites haldol ativan cogentin finasteride nursing lamictal and hormonal contraception can you take zoloft and zantac anadin extra pain relief ibuprofen how long did it take for zantac to help your baby can dramamine lower blood pressure why do you take prometrium at night zantac ranitidine hcl 150mg cyklokapron safe breastfeeding hair loss after paxil how long before lamictal starts working depo provera how long does period last differin vs retin a for wrinkles trazodone dosage sleep aid diamox hyperventilation aspirin ibuprofen cross sensitivity anacin more drug_side_effects does aricept cause dry mouth cytoxan mesna lupus triamcinolone and lidocaine injection tegretol xr website clindamycin phosphate vs clindamycin hydrochloride prolonged period with depo provera cytoxan protocol for lupus metoprolol side effects vision problems aspirin allergy and celebrex diamox metabolism up to date finasteride isotretinoin and rhinoplasty is topamax a blood thinner skin rash from isotretinoin problems with serevent using dutasteride and finasteride together topamax high heart rate what is arcoxia good for difference between fosamax fosavance avodart cancer prevention prostate what's the difference between atenolol and metoprolol is it okay to take aleve and vicodin buy diamox online no prescription tamsulosin dutasteride side effects neurontin patient assistance program application depo provera national drug code dulcolax advertisement philippines tretinoin function can neurontin cause hand tremors how long should i take fosamax lamictal and thyroid function lexapro and diltiazem diltiazem hcl mims revia naltrexone side effects is propranolol hair loss reversible what type of hair loss does propecia work for detrol qt prolongation prozac and tryptophan provigil unlabeled use naltrexone side effects reviews minoxidil with finasteride topical cyklokapron how long to work metoprolol hatasa how long will finasteride last difference between aspirin and ibuprofen topamax causes birth defects how to lose weight with dulcolax lamictal zyprexa aricept and aspirin tegretol and abilify interaction pregnant and topamax anacin rf value metoprolol atenolol same what is the use of hydroquinone tretinoin missed one dose lamictal can i use aldara after expiration date topamax and lexapro for bipolar topamax 25 mg bipolar neurontin and pristiq proton pump inhibitor zantac neurontin sep buy benzac ac wash how to use benzoyl peroxide and tretinoin together took dulcolax cramping is differin good for hormonal acne restarting lamictal after discontinuation no reaction to aldara where to buy dulcolax balance time for neurontin to work tretinoin angiogenesis l-carnitine isotretinoin doctors prescribing low dose naltrexone avodart .5 mg side effects is clindamycin good for pregnancy estate agents in artane tretinoin and rosehip oil provera stop taking how many dramamine can i take meclizine dailymed pregnant while depo provera can i take tums while taking zantac tretinoin for deep acne scars types of metoprolol delsym and lamictal atrovent overdosis enlarged prostate finasteride will triamcinolone acetonide cream help acne is it safe to take dramamine everyday meclizine overdose effects dilantin toxic side effects intrathecal baclofen pump problems diamox pharmacy how long does it take for tretinoin to work metoprolol levitra aldara immune system side effects can you use differin on your back when to use zantac for infants aldara tiredness generic cytoxan drinking alcohol while taking dilantin can xeloda kill you atrovent annual sales can you take neurontin with flexeril warfarin interaction with calcium natural source of metoprolol avodart for hair loss 2011 viagra canada shop erectile dysfunction fosamax and gfr how do you get off dilantin tretinoin and benzaclin zantac syrup dosage for babies use of metoprolol succinate tablets weight loss on 50 mg of topamax alpha hydroxy vs tretinoin provigil first time topamax medication for migraines topamax used to treat alcoholism tretinoin for sale philippines neurontin for bipolar depression how common is weight loss with zoloft baclofen compared to norco tretinoin pharmacology does coumadin cause hair loss can you drink alcohol after taking zantac isotretinoin peripheral neuropathy trileptal muscle aches is clindamycin good for an abscessed tooth avodart capsule molle fosamax and water baclofen pump noise naltrexone and parkinson's disease does topamax cause low blood sugar best price for isotretinoin does topamax cause cold sores topamax wonder drug xalatan eye drop applicator how long do naltrexone implants last elocon receptfritt can baclofen cause brain damage diamox for eyes lamictal increasing mania how much dramamine do i give my cat aspirin and lipitor interaction isotretinoin dreams can my baby take zantac and mylicon reminyl patient information tretinoin microsphere gel .1 atrovent dosage mdi loratadine and lamictal olanzapine increased prolactin tretinoin cream use with moisturizer does topamax show up a drug test when does zantac take effect clindamycin how long to work acne how do i take meclizine leukeran online pharmacy what is the dose of dutasteride price of generic imitrex tretinoin for eczema prometrium and dysfunctional uterine bleeding tretinoin cream dosage acne asacol drug card chemotherapy drugs xeloda use of lioresal provigil approved for fibromyalgia is triamcinolone acetonide used for boils mediklin clindamycin phosphate 1 2 usp enalapril calcium channel blocker how to apply clindamycin phosphate topical solution sinemet 25 100 side effects lariam tab 8 st prograf maker difference entre tegretol et trileptal finasteride 0.2mg side effects prelief and zantac does zantac show up as methamphetamine cheapest price toprol xl tretinoin results acne is zantac okay to take when pregnant lamictal withdrawal 100 mg topamax and zoloft prograf expiration date aldara cream genital warts side effects metformin weight loss 3 months tylenol 3 and zantac what is the cost of dutasteride can clindamycin be used to treat a cold elocon cream for vitiligo tegretol psychiatric use mol wt of atorvastatin calcium upper age limit for depo provera neurontin and nuvaring spironolactone 50 mg for weight loss neurontin hair loss pfizer dilantin discount card finasteride generic uk isotretinoin ipledge fda is baclofen bad clarithromycin abbreviation arava hostel price isotretinoin 4 wochen keppra xr and lamictal why is danazol used for hereditary angioedema hydrea 60 provera hormone treatment clindamycin yellow eyes how to use hydroquinone with tretinoin zantac 150 dissolve lamictal for bipolar ii disorder user reviews buscopan baclofen isotretinoin japan cytoxan mechanism of action purinethol cmi lamictal vs topamax for seizures strontium and actonel benefits of clindamycin and nicotinamide gel adverse reactions to aldara blisters from aldara clindamycin tacrolimus 0.05 tretinoin reviews stieva tretinoin gel clindamycin d test positive olanzapine wikipedia english how long does it take for topamax to cause weight loss discount for asacol prometrium sublingual tretinoin pseudotumor cerebri depo provera and false negative pregnancy test differin resenha tricor weight loss provera price philippines holding tronchetti provera prograf strengths neurontin for lyrica withdrawal what cycle day to start provera zantac liquid package insert olanzapine usage can lamictal make you irritable dilantin solubility imuran side effects reviews how to you pronounce metoprolol pkd tegretol controlled release metoprolol formulations how long does diltiazem er stay in your system is hydrocodone like aspirin clindamycin forced degradation lamictal side effects nausea tretinoin 12 weeks methotrexate and breast augmentation buy obagi tretinoin cream 0.05 metoprolol from canada differin with bha is dilantin compatible with d5w does zantac work for itching how to take oral clindamycin for acne naltrexone is a narcotic topamax rta how long before zantac for infants works solubility of clindamycin phosphate aricept and abilify baclofen lower blood pressure does neurontin cause bad dreams tretinoin cream flaky skin metformin zantac drug interaction naltrexone 6 mg depo provera company website active ingredient in aldara cream clindamycin hydrochloride drops cats side effects tegretol rm retail price of metoprolol atrovent and bph tamsulosin for erectile dysfunction olanzapine carcinogenicity frequent urination while taking topamax zosyn and clindamycin coverage buy clindamycin gel for acne medicine called trileptal how to use a dulcolax suppository laxative avodart pdf olanzapine crush topamax rosacea forum pompe lioresal gastritis and zantac topamax and tenuate trileptal tontura stieva a tretinoin cream usp artane medscape discontinue finasteride side effects adsl eunet provera racuna finasteride baldness treatment tretinoin cream available in philippines male pattern baldness treatment finasteride overdose topamax symptoms lioresal intrathecal cost fosamax femur fracture settlements baclofen penicillin is prevacid better than zantac for infants what is clindamycin phosphate lotion used for tegretol insomnia omeprazole tegretol interaction what medications interact with dilantin klonopin and neurontin do clindamycin treat uti requip vs cabergoline zantac treatment for acid reflux tegretol causing anemia can famotidine cause weight loss glucovance nursing implications side effect from aricept nasonex zyrtec together what is the purpose of triamcinolone acetonide triamcinolone acetonide and hydrocortisone elocon cream price in india side effects mestinon tablets dramamine hydrocodone interactions ultra low dose naltrexone euphoria metoprolol dose in acute mi metoprolol 50 durchfall does asacol reduce sperm count low dose naltrexone buy online sildenafil from angina to erectile dysfunction action of tegretol ezetimibe erectile dysfunction uses of carafate what effects depo provera dramamine toddlers difference between somac and zantac metoprolol diastolic glucovance cena is meclizine the same as benadryl alternative medications to metoprolol can toprol xl cause anxiety how long after stopping topamax can i get pregnant aricept agitation zantac to stop vomiting reminyl tabletta zantac 150 printable coupon clindamycin gi bleed topamax and lymphadenopathy wellbutrin weight loss depression medicare cpt code for clindamycin concerta and weight loss treatment finasteride hair loss dose wellbutrin combined with lamictal requip gsk rogaine tretinoin does olanzapine cause weight loss triamcinolone and eucerin compound does nifedipine cause weight loss aspirin vs lipitor clindamycin iv beipackzettel taking provera when will period start diltiazem sinus tachycardia what is the difference between provera and birth control what comes after xeloda isotretinoin eiter requip magic does provera cause false positive pregnancy test isotretinoin and contact lenses glaxosmithkline marketing strategy for requip toprol kidney stones glaucoma xalatan side effects mestinon and blood sugar toprol and vitamin d tretinoin mechanism acne aspirin and esomeprazole combination avodart adverse effects where to buy meclizine hcl does lamictal cause bloating actonel in india inflammation ibuprofen or aspirin baclofen pump brands ms contin neurontin interaction between zoloft and neurontin most common side effects of sinemet naltrexone joint pain zantac whilst pregnant kamagra weight loss buy parlodel neurontin dosage 300 mg can i take zantac with amoxicillin neurontin for night sweats metoprolol low pulse rate dilantin cardiac toxicity aldara common warts topamax and halcion requip dosering using differin for acne tretinoin cream 0.05 uk olanzapine treats what tegretol buzz nystatin and triamcinolone acetonide cream perineum aricept anoxic brain injury how fast aldara work salicylic acid differin gel depo provera drug company bactrim erectile dysfunction provigil 200 mg compared to adderall is zantac alkaline mixing zoloft and aspirin does zantac help anxiety lawsuit against topamax where can i buy imitrex procardia xl hair loss topamax phentermine diet isotretinoin retinol equivalent depo provera and weight loss pills can you take imitrex and phentermine non prescription tretinoin gel clindamycin chlamydia pneumoniae breakout from tretinoin tretinoin and waxing tretinoin cream or gel can you take 2 aleve and 2 tylenol provera 10mg to stop bleeding isotretinoin and calcium isotretinoin and memory loss can i take topamax and wellbutrin together haldol trazodone interactions meclizine 20 mg can guys take clindamycin artane orphanage dublin dosage of tegretol xr is tretinoin good for blackheads tretinoin cream clindamycin phosphate isotretinoin and eyes long term olanzapine use depo provera shot smoking orange and white capsule dilantin 100mg neurontin side effect headache thuoc aricept 5mg olanzapine and sertraline together detrol and incontinence baby zantac cause gas clindamycin topical mrsa dilantin overdose signs symptoms dilantin mixed with alcohol got pregnant on depo provera shot tegretol fetal effects provera tablets to delay period depo provera for female dogs sunflowers florist artane my dog ate a topamax pill clindamycin foam for back acne triamcinolone acetonide for macular degeneration is there a substitute for diltiazem clindamycin 300 und antibabypille fosamax ny times baclofen 10 ml is it safe to take excedrin and imitrex d test clindamycin wikipedia metoprolol tartrate drug test zantac over the counter or prescription aygestin for birth control triamcinolone for dme finasteride pricing walmart light period after provera pictures online provera tekuceg racuna